SWEETS SELECTION
Our sweets selection menu is a curated selection of desserts and confections designed to satisfy your cravings for sugary, indulgent delights.
Cookie of the Week
One flavor. One week. Always made fresh. Every week we feature a new, handcrafted cookie flavor—baked from scratch and styled the Simply Vainilla way. Think soft centers, golden edges, and just the right amount of sweetness. Available in limited quantities while they last! Follow @simplyvainilla to see what we’re baking next 🤎
Dozen Brown Butter Guava Cheesecake Cookie
Golden, gooey, and full of tropical comfort. This cookie starts with a rich brown butter dough—nutty, soft, and just a little crisp around the edges. Inside? A sweet guava center and creamy cheesecake filling that melt together in every bite. It’s warm, tangy, and just the right amount of indulgent. Tropical nostalgia meets cozy bakery vibes.
$25.00
Gourmet Cookies
Our gourmet cookie is a luxurious and elevated take on the classic treat, crafted with premium, high-quality ingredients and intricate flavors that delight the senses.
Dozen Brown Butter Chocolate Hazelnut & Nutella filled Cookie
Drown butter chocolate hazelnut cookie fille with Nutella.
$28.00
Dozen Brown Butter Chocolate Chips
Our Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie is a rich, indulgent twist on the classic chocolate chip cookie, where the deep, nutty flavor of brown butter elevates every bite. The cookie features a golden-brown exterior that’s crisp at the edges, giving way to a soft and chewy center.
$25.00
Dozen Brown Butter Strawberry Cream Cookie
Brown Butter Cookie with white chocolate, chewy strawberry bites and cheesecake filling.
$25.00
Dozen Brown Butter Guava Cheesecake Cookie
Golden, gooey, and full of tropical comfort. This cookie starts with a rich brown butter dough—nutty, soft, and just a little crisp around the edges. Inside? A sweet guava center and creamy cheesecake filling that melt together in every bite. It’s warm, tangy, and just the right amount of indulgent. Tropical nostalgia meets cozy bakery vibes.
$25.00
Custom Cupcakes
Indulge in the sweet perfection of our custom cupcakes—handcrafted to match your unique vision and taste! Whether you're celebrating a birthday, wedding, baby shower, or just treating yourself, our cupcakes are made to order with the finest ingredients and endless customization options. Choose from a variety of flavors, fillings, frostings, and beautifully personalized designs to make every bite as memorable as the moment. Sweet, stylish, and made just for you!
Dozen Cupcakes
Sweet, simple, and styled to match your moment. Each cupcake is baked from scratch and finished with soft, elegant details—from delicate florals and smooth piping to custom toppers and color palettes. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, baby shower, or just want something pretty and personal, our custom cupcakes are made to feel like you. Available by the dozen. Custom themes, flavors, and fillings welcome.
Custom Cupcakes
$42.00
Themed Cupcakes
$54.00
Custom Cakes
Celebrate sweet moments with a cake made just for you. Our custom cakes are handcrafted from scratch with premium ingredients, tailored to match your vision, theme, and flavor cravings. Whether you’re dreaming of a whimsical birthday cake, a romantic wedding centerpiece, or a one-of-a-kind design for a special occasion, we’ll bring your ideas to life—layer by delicious layer. Choose your size, flavor, fillings, and design. From classic vanilla and rich chocolate to fruity favorites and unique combos, your custom cake is made to impress—and taste unforgettable. Contact us for a quote.
Custom Cakes
At Simply Vainilla, every cake is made to order and designed just for you. From soft, romantic textures to clean, minimalist designs, we bring your vision to life in the sweetest way. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, baby shower, wedding, or just because—each cake is crafted with care, style, and intention. Choose your size, color palette, and aesthetic—we’ll handle the rest. Let’s create something beautiful (and delicious) together.
$0
Mini Cake Gift Box
A petite celebration in every box. Perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, or just-because surprises, our mini cake and cupcake gift boxes are handcrafted, softly styled, and always sweet. Choose your cake flavor, frosting style, and box size—each one is topped with elegant details and ready to gift. Decorated to match your occasion. Always baked with love.
Mini Cake Cupcake Gift Box
A sweet little luxury, wrapped and ready to wow. Our Gift Box Mini Cakes are crafted to look like elegant presents—complete with soft buttercream, a delicate ribbon bow, and a touch of Simply Vainilla charm. Perfect for birthdays, bridesmaid proposals, baby showers, party favor or any special moment worth celebrating. Each mini cake is made to order in your choice of color palette and flavor. Now available as a set for even more sweetness: Mini Cake + 2 Cupcakes A small but stunning treat box—perfect for personal gifting or intimate surprises. Mini Cake + 5 Cupcakes Just the right amount of indulgence for small gatherings, team gifts, or stylish celebrations. All cakes available in vanilla bean with your choice of filling. Contact us for more flavor options.
Mini Cupcake with 2 cupcakes
$60.00
Mini Cake with 5 Cupcakes
$75.00
Gift Sweet Boxes
For when only the best will do. Our premium sweets box is curated with artisanal confections, gourmet sweets and elegant packaging that makes an unforgettable impression. Ideal for high-end gifts, client appreciation, or celebrating life’s finer moments.
Brownie or Blondie Gift Boxes
Fudgy, rich, and beautifully wrapped—decorated for any occasion. Each brownie or blondie is handcrafted from scratch and packaged with care, then styled to match your celebration. Whether you’re sending a sweet thank-you, surprising someone on their birthday, or adding a treat to your dessert table, our brownie gift boxes are made to impress. Customizable by size, flavor, and theme—wrapped in soft tones and elegant details for that signature Simply Vainilla touch.
Events Dessert Tables
Events Dessert Tables Sweeten your celebration with a show-stopping dessert table. Our custom dessert tables are styled to match your event and filled with an irresistible variety of handcrafted treats—from cupcakes, cookies, and cake pops to macarons, mini tarts, brownies, and more. Whether it’s elegant and romantic or fun and colorful, we design each table to be a delicious centerpiece that guests will remember long after the last bite. Perfect for weddings, baby showers, birthdays, corporate events, and everything in between. We’ll work with your theme, color palette, and favorite flavors to create a beautiful, cohesive setup that tastes as good as it looks. Contact us for more details!
Breakfast/Brunch Boxes
A cozy morning, boxed beautifully. Whether you're celebrating a special morning or just treating yourself, our brunch boxes are thoughtfully curated with a balance of sweet and savory, freshly baked and ready to enjoy. Perfect for birthdays, bridal brunches, baby showers, client gifts—or just a slow Sunday. Available in personal, duo, or group sizes. Custom add-ons available. Contact us for more details.
Wedding Cakes
Refined, romantic, and made just for you. Our custom wedding cakes are designed with intention and styled with simplicity. From soft florals and delicate textures to smooth finishes and clean lines, each cake is handcrafted to reflect your vision and elevate your celebration. We’ll work with your color palette, aesthetic, and flavor preferences to create a cake that feels like you—beautiful, memorable, and completely delicious. Tasting boxes and design consultations available by request.
Custom Wedding Cakes
💍 Custom Wedding Cakes Your wedding cake should be as timeless and beautiful as your day. At Simply Vainilla, we design elegant, custom cakes that reflect your vision—minimalist, romantic, and made with intention. How to Order: Submit an Inquiry Use our custom cake form to share your wedding date, guest count, style inspiration, and any special details. Design Consultation We’ll follow up to confirm availability and schedule a design consultation (email or phone). We’ll talk color palette, mood, floral details, and more. Receive Your Quote After finalizing the design direction, you’ll receive a custom quote based on our à la carte pricing. Secure Your Date A 50% deposit secures your spot on our calendar. The remaining balance is due 2 weeks before your event. The Big Day We’ll deliver your cake with care and style—ready to be the centerpiece of your celebration. Delivery available throughout the Tampa Bay area. All designs are tailored to your vision, using your selected flavors and colors. 📋 Inquiry Form Fields: Name Email Phone Number Wedding Date Venue / Location Estimated Guest Count Design Style or Theme (ex: romantic, minimalist, rustic, etc.) Color Palette Inspiration Images (upload field) Cake Flavor Preference (optional dropdown or text box) Any Other Details or Notes
$0
